This is a pretty long post, but I've been working on it for days now, so please read it. Go ahead and get a cup of coffee and a snack. I'll wait. Oh, come on. Do you know how many LINKS are in this thing? Thanks. And JCK and Mrs. G. definitely need to read to the end. Or at least skip to the end. :)
I have written about mountaintop removal a few times now. Here and here and here and here.
And here are a few more articles. All of these were posted on Common Dreams and were forwarded to me by my good friend Philip in Canada.
Bush's Coal Giveaway originally in the Huffington Post
First Nationwide Opinion Poll on Mountaintop Removal from EarthJustice
Nell Levin's Editorial in The Tennessean
Here's the video (and the link in case the video doesn't work) for Ms. Levin's song, "Don't Blow Up the Mountain."
At minute 1:39, look on the bottom right corner at the rock truck. It looks tiny next to the explosion, doesn't it? To give you an idea of the magnitude, that rock truck could hold a couple of cars and maybe a minivan.
________________________
Sometime in March, a coal company Who Shall Not Be Named began working on a piece of land right next to the road we usually travel to get to town. I wish I'd known, because I would have taken some true "before" pictures. This company has several different mine operations in our county alone, and others in eastern Kentucky, as well as Virginia, West Virginia, and Illinois. Here is the description of our local mining operations from the company's own website.
Nearly all of the coal is marketed run-of-mine. Overburden is
removed by front-end loaders, end dumps, bulldozers and blast
casting. Coal is transported by on-highway trucks from the mines
to the Kentucky River Loading rail loadout, which is served by CSX.
Some coal is direct shipped to the customer by truck from the mine pits.
We estimate that ICG Hazard controls 38.8 million tons of coal
reserves, plus 1.9 million tons of coal that is classified as
non-reserve coal deposits. Approximately 57% of ICG Hazard’s
reserves are leased.
Translation:"overburden is removed" - Overburden is the mountain. All the trees, rocks, and dirt that cover up the coal seam are blasted apart, then shoved off of the coal using the equipment listed. These are big trucks. Some of them are so big they come labeled as "some assembly required."
"reserves are leased" - The company does not own all of the land it is mining. The owners have sold the mineral rights, usually for not remotely what they're worth. If you need an analogy, let's say you sell the insulation rights to your house. (
OK, it's far fetched, work with me here.) Someone comes in and gets all the insulation out of your house and pays you for it. What's the quickest, cheapest way to get at the insulation? Tear out the walls. Sure, there is a clause in the contract requiring them to put everything back the way it was, but who's going to enforce it? When you complain they just laugh at you. And there you sit with your little insulation rights pittance that won't begin to cover the cost of repairing your house, and even if it did, it will never be right.
The railroad track runs next to the river below our house. The CSX trains loaded with coal run daily.
Most of the coal operations in eastern Kentucky are owned by out-of-state entities. However, there is a small operation near us which seems to be the exception. I've never seen their trucks overloaded, the company diligently maintains the portion of the road used by the trucks (unlike the rest of the road, which is maintained, or rather is not, by the county), and the owners give very generously to important causes in the community. (By contrast, one landowner who got $80 million for 90 acres of land was approached by an organization for a donation. He reached deep into that $80 million and offered $100. But in his defense, he had to build a 35,000-square-foot house. No, that's not too many zeros. Thirty-five thousand square feet.)
(Falling off soap box; picture time! I can hear the collective sigh of relief from here. Stop it, you're fogging up my monitor.)So if that imagery isn't enough for you, here it is in real life. I took some pictures in mid-May with my regular camera so the scanned quality may not be up to par. There was a nice little spot right next to the road that I could pull the car into and take a bunch of pictures. This is what it looked like in May. This is basically a valley fill. The dirt from the top of the mountain is filling in the valley around it.I started at the road and went left 180 degrees. The last picture is actually 3 pictures scanned together. The tree in the second and third pictures is the same.



And this is the view from that same exact spot on November 10.

So I moved down the road a few hundred yards to get these. Pretend they're lined up and you're looking from left to right about 180 degrees.




It only took six months for this piece of property to look like this. Now multiply that by the number of mining sites in this area alone, multiplied by all the other sites operated by this one company, multiplied by all the other companies, multiplied by the number of states, multiplied over the last 40 years . . .
Our local officials claim that we need all this flat land for new businesses. A number of businesses, including the hospital, are built on top of a site mined in the 70s using underground methods. Underground mining has its own set of problems. Notably, after all the coal is out you have a lot of caves. Dirt caves, not rock caves. So put a big heavy building on top of that, and a lot of times you get a cave in, technically known as subsidence.
Two hotels have lost entire wings due to subsidence. Taco Bell is shored up by huge iron posts and none of the doors fit right anymore. The hospital cafeteria sank 6 inches just last year. Every building up there has cracks in the foundations. However, none of these businesses are rushing to build on that lovely newly-created flat land that once was a useless old mountain. Why?
No water.
Mountaintop removal destroys water sources. Water would have to be pumped in and the expense is prohibitive, even to businesses who get all kinds of tax incentives from the state to come here (that's another post).
Kentuckians For The Commonwealth provided me with this image produced by
Appalachian Voices. The green part shows the city of Lexington in Fayette County (county population 260,512). The red overlay represents the Starfire mine site which occupies 3 counties of eastern Kentucky.
Total population of the three counties: 63,139 (2000 census). No one lives on the mine site (it's been designated as a wildlife management area and the University of Kentucky is doing tree growing experiments on it, as well as other useful stuff). However, it's all nice and flat now, and we've got many, many more sites available for the 200,000 people who are no doubt going to flock to build businesses on the flat land available in eastern Kentucky. What's that? Oh, employment? Schools? Services? I'm sure something will turn up . . .

So this is what's going on just in Appalachia. And just in my little tiny corner of it. By no means is mining limited to this area. Montana, Arizona, New Mexico, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Georgia, Alabama (insert your state here) are all affected, not necessarily by coal mining, but by something someone wants to dig out of the ground.
Extractive industries affect every state (and other countries, but I have to focus here. I know it may be too late, but bear with me). And not just the human population. All those trees that were cut down meant thousands of birds and animals were made homeless. We just keep encroaching. Some plant and animal species no longer exist thanks to the way we dig everything up willy nilly. And as the trees which provide us with oxygen disappear, our air quality diminishes.
In the U.S., the Bureau of Land Management is in charge of, well, land management. (Yeah, it was a stretch.) But it's in charge of FEDERAL lands. (The Office of Surface Mining deals with coal. Sort of. When they feel like it and if it doesn't offend anyone.) And as with any government agency, the BLM finds itself in an
untenable situation of its own making.
In the continuing effort to seize control of every piece of property that might make money for someone, the BLM rounded up all the wild horses in the West and confined them to holding areas. Surprise, surprise, it hasn't worked. Now they're considering euthanizing some of these horses. Like 30,000 (the number includes wild burros). As appalling as that is, the wild horse population isn't much higher than 30,000, down from 2,000,000 100 years ago.
But there is an effort to stop this. Saving the American Wild Horse has produced a documentary to call attention to the plight of these animals. Here's the
PSA, and here's the
call to action outlining what you can do. (As it happens, one of my state senators is on the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, so I sent him an email request to get the bill out of committee. I send him lots of emails. As far as I know, he's never done anything I've ever asked. But there's a first time for everything.) Here is a list of the
Senate committee members so you can check to see if someone from your state is on it.
And once we save the horses, we can go back to the problem of finding alternatives to coal energy. Like wind and sun.
Do you live near mining operations? Write a post with some pictures and I'll link to it.